AI Smells: How to Immediately Spot AI Slop

Along with career wisdom from the Pentagon, data visualization about word meaning, and roles paying $250k+

Welcome to this week’s edition of The DesAI Digest. We’ll cover:

  • 🤖 AI Tactic = AI Smells

  • ⚡️ Execution Insight = Completed Staff Work

  • 🧠 Curiosity Corner = Perceptions of Probability 🔢 

  • 💼 Job Board = Cash Out ($250k+) in Customer-Facing Roles 📢 

🤖 AI Tactic

AI Smells

In programming, there are “code smells” — a code smell is any characteristic of source code that hints at a deeper problem. Jeff Atwood, founder of coding Q&A site Stack Overflow, keeps a long list of code smells.

These days, I’m seeing more and more AI smells, the telltale signs that someone has used poorly prompted AI to generate slop.

If you want the list of AI smells, please sign up for the newsletter :) 

⚡️ Execution Insight

Completed Staff Work

Completed Staff Work” was a memo distributed to staff officers during WWII and reprinted by Thomas Watson for staff at IBM. It describes the optimal way to present a problem and solution to your commanding officer (or manager in a corporate setting).

In simple terms, the memo asserts that you should work out all the details of a single “completed action” to take in response to a problem, not to present things piecemeal. The goal is to advise your manager what to do for their approval or disapproval, not to ask them what to do.

The memo concludes with a great test of work quality — one that we should all apply to our work:

If you were the chief, would you be willing to sign the paper you have presented, and stake your professional reputation on its being right?

🧠 Curiosity Corner

Perceptions of Probability 🔢

I am generally interested in how people communicate and interpret each other’s meaning. (I do write a newsletter, after all).

So one chart I keep coming back to is this one that maps “perceptions of probability”:

The raw data came from /r/samplesize responses to the following question: What [probability/number] would you assign to the phrase "[phrase]"?

Probability words feel precise, but they aren’t. Each curve shows what people really mean when they say things like “likely” or “highly unlikely.” The spread is huge!

Take “about even.” Most people understandably call that 50%. But look at “we believe.” One person says it’s a 60% chance, another claims 80%. “Highly likely”? You’ll see guesses from 70% all the way to 95%.

It’s interesting to me that we all use the same words, but everyone’s mental number is different.

💼 Job Board

Cash Out ($250k+) in Customer-Facing Roles 📢 

Here are the 3 most interesting remote job openings I’ve seen this week:

If you want the jobs, please sign up for the newsletter :) 

That’s it for this week.

-Rahul from The DesAI Digest

P.S. Reply back to this email with a business challenge you’re facing! I’d love to help.

P.P.S. if you liked this, forward it to a friend. And if you hated it, forward it to an enemy.